Showing posts with label Peter Miesler. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Peter Miesler. Show all posts

Monday, August 27, 2018

The Missing Key to Stephen Gould’s “Nonoverlapping Magisteria.”

I’m in the process of mailing out copies of this to various Democratic Party representatives  (plus scientists and science communicators, under different introductions) and want to share it at this blog.  Perhaps it'll resonate with someone out there.
_________________________________________________________________________________________

May I ask for a moment of your time please.

The Situation:
The disconnected-from-physical-reality GOP attacks on climate science have reached horrifying levels with the Trump Administration.  Yet science loving rationalists, pluralists, progressives, liberals, Democrats still haven’t developed effective messaging for directly confronting the most childish of Republican arguments and trains of ill-logic.  Why?  Mainly because rationalists rather sidestep their willful ignorance.  This acquiescence to GOP's nonsense has been a fatal error for our national dialogue and general state of understanding.

Arguing with contrarians should not be seen as an exercise in futility, since those are teaching opportunity for explaining the simple logical geophysical reasoning that puts the lie to disingenuous “skeptical" arguments for onlookers from our own side.  Folks who probably don’t understand the science and would gain much from a simple lesson.

Even on this fateful US election eve, little effort seems to be getting expended to help geographically dispersed individual activists, of diverse talents, network with like-minded for sharing information, developing ideas, cross-breeding and strategizing.  Such efforts would facilitate a better appreciation for what we are all about, while encouraging a sense of community and pro-active cooperation. 

Why try to reach out to Democratic Party representatives and candidates:
Because only through elected Democratic Party representatives do We The People have a chance of successfully turning back this ruthless attack on rationality and on our way of government and public discourse.  An attack that’s been supercharged under the Trump Administration’s Me First reign.

Why do this:
I live out in the Colorado hinterlands so that’s why I’m asking for your help to network with others interested in more effectively defending science in the face of the GOP’s malicious juvenile illogic and internet brainwashing through uncontested astro-turfing efforts.

I’m hoping the following might connect with someone on your offices’ environmental, science, global warming team.  If you see any value in the following please do share, with others who may understand what I’m trying to say with these essays and blog posts.  Any feedback, encouragement, networking, or support would be much appreciated.   
   
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
    
The Missing Key to Stephen Gould’s
“Nonoverlapping Magisteria”











“… missing was a much more fundamental division crying out for recognition.  Specifically,                                        
the magisteria of Physical Reality vs the magisteria of our Human Mindscape. …”

Selected blog posts, addendum to Missing Key to Gould's 'Nonoverlapping Magisteria' essay.

I need help to network with others who understand what I’m trying to say with these essays and blog posts.
Any feedback, encouragement, networking, or support would be much appreciated.  
Peter Miesler aka citizenschallenge @ gmail.com 
P.O.Box 56, Durango, Colorado 81302

Regarding - Stephen Gould, who with Niles Eldredge, introduced the world to evolutionary Punctuated Equilibrium in 1972:

Exploring the Map v Territory Problem - via the Brown Ocean Effect and Dr. Trenberth

Colorado Floods - statistical certainty vs geophysical realities - 2013

2018, now what? Considering the Republican Dialogue Problem in 14 VERSES.

CO2 Science - Blue team: "Pruitt, it's certain as certain gets! It's the physics! Don't you know?

CO2 Science - Pruitt, proof is in the pudding! Impossible Modern Marvels

(Sd7) Abuse of Our Free Speech Rights (LandscapesAndCycles - Jim Steele) (FCFP)

(Sd3) Mr.GOP don't buy Jim Steele's Fraud - LandscapesAndCycles

(Sd1) Revisiting Jim Steele's LandscapesAndCycles Fraud - 
            An index of past research - Steele debate #1

Fruits of Ignoring Deliberate Deception

I am an Earth Centrist.

Earth Centrist ponders, polite or honest?

______________________________________________________________________

Exploring the Map v Territory Problem - via the Brown Ocean Effect and Dr. Trenberth

“… During the Q&A I had a chance to ask Dr.Trenberth, (58:00 video 3/3) 

“I’d like to bring it back to Hurricane Harvey, can you explain what the Brown Ocean Effect is and how it impacts landfall hurricanes such as Harvey?”

Dr. Trenberth responded,  “What, what is this?” and stopped.  He caught me by surprise, after a couple beats I collected my thoughts and responded, 

“The ‘Brown Ocean Effect is about land surface areas getting so saturated with hot water that when a hurricane comes over the land it starts sucking up the heat and moisture.” 

I was startled at Dr. Trenberth’s halting response.  Rather than reviewing what’s been written in the literature, he went back to the a,b,c’s of hurricanes.  Thing is, none of that was being questioned.  It was this ominous new environmental factor that I wanted to learn more about, but that Dr. Trenberth seemed to not want to talk about.  

His 450 word two part response thankfully ended with: 

“So that's presumably the brown ocean effect that if you've dumped a whole lot of water on the land there is a capability for some moisture to reevaporate back into the atmosphere to help refuel the storm if you like.”

I believe his reluctance can be understood by considering his ending sentence to part one: 

“You know having a big dumping of water over land didn't hurt but I don't know just how much it helped either.  That's the sort of thing that we can sort out a bit more with experiments with models at some later point.”   

The true cartographer, until he can map it with his models and empirically define its details, nothing is more than a suggestion.  Is this something to complain about?  NO!  

Profiles in Criminality, Grenon Bro's and Trump the traitor

America's President's Apparent Health Advisors:  Mark Grenon, Joseph Grenon, Jordan Grenon, and Jonathan Grenon sell and distribute ...

Popular Posts